Marvel Heroes Collide in Civil War
WhileAvengers Disassembledstarted it all, and the likes ofHouse of MandSecret Invasioncertainly have their merits, Civil War is really the mega Marvel event of the 2000s. Hero vs Hero, Villains turned ‘Heroes,’ and answers to the age old question – Who would win in a fight: Captain America or Iron Man?
Whether we’re talking sales, attention, or sheer scale, Civil War was a watershed moment for event-driven comics (for better or worse). While it’s hardly the first ever event featuring tie-ins, Civil War marked the moment in the 2000’s were nearly every title was pulled into an event-specific plot. Don’t believe me? Check out the the official issue-by-issue reading order belowcompared to House of M. Just a bit more… expansive.
On top of all that, Civil War is the inspiration for the third Captain America Marvel movie, and the start of MCU Phase 3, featuring the crossover inclusion of Robert Downey Jr.’s Iron Man and just about every hero we’ve seen to date.
当然，这是一本有趣的读物(当然，这需要一个好的指导来引导连续性)。下面你会发现我对内战收集贸易的首选订单，然后是每个捆绑销售的一个问题一个问题的细分。一如既往，希望你喜欢!If you have questions or concerns,let me hear about it, orlet’s talk on Twitter!
Previously:Decimation & Tie-Ins
Support For Comic Book Herald:
Comic Book Herald is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a qualifying affiliate commission.
Comic Book Herald’s reading orders and guides are also made possible byreader support on Patreon, and generous reader donations.
Any size contribution will help keep CBH alive and full of new comics guides and content. SupportCBH on Patreonforexclusive rewards, orDonate here!感谢您的阅读!
Elsewhere:Looking forCivil War II (2016)?
Civil War Trade Reading Timeline
- The Road to Civil War
- Civil War
- 正如我在House of M阅读指南中提到的，我更喜欢在阅读其他收集的交易之前阅读主要事件。然后，您可以根据您认为合适的情况，使用更好的搭配交易填充细节。也就是说，之后的主要事件事件显然会与以下许多交易重叠。为了避免这种情况，我建议使用以下每个问题的阅读指南。这样，你就可以把你在任何一个交易中的位置收藏起来，就像你在阅读一个连贯的故事一样。
- Civil War: Front Line
- One of the best tie-in trades, but I would pay some attention to the issue-by-issue breakdown as it relates to the primary Civil War story arc. The linked trade collects all of the Front Line tie-in, but you can also buy the collection in two installments if you’ve already read part or something.
- The Amazing Spider-Man: Civil War
- Civil War: Peter Parker, Sensational Spider-Man
- New Avengers, Vol 5: Civil War
- Captain America: Civil War
- Marvel has since recollected these issues asCivil War: Captain America/Iron Man
. This collection lumps the Cap issues with the Iron Man issues (listed last in the trade order) below.
- Marvel has since recollected these issues asCivil War: Captain America/Iron Man
- Wolverine: Civil War
- Ms. Marvel: Civil War
- Fantastic Four: Civil War
- Punisher War Journal: Civil War
- Civil War: Thunderbolts
- Civil War: X-Men Universe
- Civil War: X-Men
- Civil War: Young Avengers & Runaways
- Civil War: War Crimes
- Black Panther: Civil War
- Iron Man: Civil War
- This trade collection gets mildly confusing for a couple reasons. 1) The Amazon.com description is dead wrong. It claims this trade also collects the Captain America Civil War issues, which is simply not true (for that you can see… you guessed it, the Captain America Civil War trade). 2) It includes Civil War: The Confession, conversations between Iron Man & Captain America after the war. This particular issue (which is a FANTASTIC one from Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev) occurs deeper into Marvel continuity than the Civil War timeline should really include. I would recommend saving the issue until after you’ve read the next volume of Captain America and possibly also Iron Man.
Main Marvel Characters in Civil War
Below you’ll find reading orders for certain characters playing a prominent role in Captain America: Civil War, a major installment in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Note that these reading orders are for the character’s entire history in the Marvel Universe, and not just their involvement in Civil War. For just Civil War, see the Marvel Unlimited issue by issue reading order below.
Marvel Unlimited Event Reading Order
The Road to Civil War
- Amazing Spider-Man #529
- New Avengers: Illuminati
- Amazing Spider-Man #530
- Fantastic Four #536 – #537
- Amazing Spider-Man #531
- Civil War: Opening Shot #1
Stamford Bomb
- Civil War #1
- She-Hulk #8
- Black Panther #17
- Wolverine #42
- New Avengers #21
- X-Factor #8
- Civil War: Front Line #1
- Amazing Spider-Man #532
The Act Passes / Sides Are Chosen
- Civil War #2
- Amazing Spider-Man #533
- Civil War: Front Line #2
- She-Hulk #9
- Dark Avengers/Thunderbolts #103
- New Avengers #22
- Blade #4
- Sensational Spider-Man #28
- X-Factor #9
- Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #11 – #13
Opening Shots
- Civil War: Front Line #3
- Heroes For Hire #1
- Civil War: Young Avengers & Runaways #1 – #4
- Dark Avengers/Thunderbolts #104 – #105
- Cable & Deadpool #30
- Fantastic Four #538
- 新x战警28号- 32号
- Not direct tie-ins but connect to Storm’s events in Black Panther #18
- Black Panther #18
- Civil War: Frontline #4
- Daredevil #87
- Another indirect tie-in that explains Daredevil’s appearances during Civil War
- Civil War: Choosing Sides #1
- Black Panther #19
- Iron Man #13
- Black Panther #20
- Civil War: Front Line #5
- Sensational Spider-Man #29 – #31
War
- Civil War #3
- Civil War #4
- Civil War: Front Line #6
- Cable & Deadpool #31 – #32
- Wolverine #43 – #45
- Captain America #22 – #23
- Civil War: Front Line #7
- Amazing Spider-Man #534
- Fantastic Four #539
- Black Panther #21 – #22
- Civil War: X-Men #1 – #4
- Heroes For Hire #2 – #3
- Ms. Marvel #6 – #8
- New Avengers #23 – #24
- Civil War: The Return
- Captain America/Iron Man: Casualties of War
- Wolverine #46 – #47
- Black Panther #23
- Captain America #24
- Civil War: Front Line #8
Introspection
- Wolverine #48
- Fantastic Four #540
- Amazing Spider-Man #535
- Civil War #5
- Punisher War Journal #1
- Fantastic Four #541
- Civil War: War Crimes #1
- Civil War: Front Line #9
- Moon Knight #7 – #10
- Fantastic Four #542
- Amazing Spider-Man #536
- Iron Man #14
- Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #14 – #16
- 叶片# 5
- Sensational Spider-Man #32 – #34
- Winter Solider: Winter Kills #1
Final Battle
- Amazing Spider-Man #537
- Black Panther #24
- Punisher War Journal #2
- Civil War #6
- Punisher War Journal #3
- New Avengers #25
- Civil War: Front Line #10
- Civil War #7
- Black Panther #25
Conclusion
- Amazing Spider-Man #538 – #539
- Fantastic Four #543
- Civil War: Front Line #11
- Ghost Rider #8
- Very loose tie-in so passable if you want to get to the real meat below.
- Captain America #25
- Civil War: Fallen Son #1 – #5
- Civil War: The Initiative #1
- Civil War: The Confession
Next:The Initiative and comics between Civil War & Secret Invasion
Heroically Support Comic Book Herald!
If you like Comic Book Herald, and are able to donate, any small contribution will help keep CBH alive and full of new comics guides and content.Donate here!Or, supportCBH on Patreonfor exclusive rewards! Or you can even check out theCBH Merch storeand get something nice with a small portion benefiting the site! Thank you for reading!
Amazing Spider-Man 536 states within the pages, twice, that it occurs after Civil War issue 5 and 6
Also, Ghost Rider issues 8-11 are considered part of Civil War, not just 8
Amazing Spider-Man 539 isn’t part of Civil War
Also 8-11 can easily be read after Civil War issue 5, you don’t need to wait until right at the end
缺失的如果?内战和如果?Fallen son as well as the Civil War Files, Civil War: Battle Damage Report and the Civil War and Fallen Son tie-in issues of the Daily Bugle
Just get all this stuff and put it in the biggest burlap sack there is and have it hurled into space via some hi-tech vehicle and be done with it forever…
你是不喜欢漫画还是指南?你想把什么东西扔进太空，为什么?
Where does house of M civil war fit into civil war or are they not related. They have the same font So it’s confusing if not related. Thanks for putting this all together!
Thanks for the great guide! Only thing I think need changing is maybe put The Confession before The Initiative #1. I think latter is a much better way to close out this guide, otherwise Ms. Marvel spoils what really happens to Cap at the end. Anyway thanks again
First, I have to say that I really enjoy the list that you have compiled. Although I haven’t yet read the stories in your order yet, I would have to say even if there is something out of order you seem to be receptive to adjustments to your list, so others that get bent out of shape should relax and just enjoy the stories.
我确实对内战时期的阅读顺序有些疑问。我还发现了其他《Civil War》列表中所包含的其他行业，我想听听你的意见:是否应该将这些游戏包括在内，如果是的话应该在哪里?你过去考虑过这些问题吗?如果考虑过，为什么没有把它们列出来呢?
Civil War Prelude: New Warriors (2015) PB
Cable & Deadpool (2004) PB Vol. 6
Civil War Companion (2007) PB
Civil War: Marvel Universe (2007) PB
Ghost Rider (2006) PB Vol. 2
Heroes For Hire (2006) PB Vol. 1
Moon Knight (2006) PB Vol. 2
X-Factor (2006) PB Vol. 2
Fallen Son: The Death of Captain America (2007) PB
Thanks for the time and I hope you can help me understand these questions.
I think Thunderbolts 106-109 happen during the Civil War too.. since Cap is involved.
X-Facotr #9 needs to be read earlier; Wolverine is still with the X-Men instead of off on a Vendetta.
Hey, Young Avengers/Runaways has spoilers for the Parental Guidance arc of Runaways, which you have in the part after Civil War.
13-18期不应该是在内战之前，而不是内战之后吗?
They definitely should be read before Civil War. Publication dates for those issues lead up to when they show up in Civil War too.
Hi! Curious where the Penance: Relentless 1-5 mini series fits in this. Do I just tack it on the end of this? I see the costume on the cover of frontline 10… also a couple other misc issues I have, not too sure where to place:
1. Civil War files: who’s side are you on? (Not to be confused with Choosing Sides)
2.Civil War: Damage Report
Thanks!
Hi! Curious where the Penance mini series fits in this. Do I just tack it on the end of this?
I’m trying to figure out what “Civil War: Fallen Son #1 – #5” is in your guide under Conclusion. At first I thought it was “Civil War: Fallen Son – The Death of Captain America #1-#5” but that’s in your next reading guide. And the Daily Bugle Fallen Son special is only one issue, not 5. Can you help me out here?
I trusted your damned order and then Frontline #6 spoiled things for me for being in the wrong place on the list. Thanks a lot. Fortunately marvel.com has the official order.
I would have hated that as a reader myself. That sucks. If you can tell me where you think issues should be placed, I will definitely take a look at updating.
Been out of comic collecting since 1991 and use this site religiously to catch up on each story arch! Thanks for all the work!
Finished reading Civil War and most related issues prior to the movie and read after seeing it that Sharon Carter recites Cap’s speech from Amazing Spider-Man #537 in the movie. Not remembering that speech, went to my ASM Civil War digital copy and saw it ended at 536! Any idea if 537 and 538 are in another Civil War related digital collection or will I have to buy the individual issues?
再次感谢!很棒的网站!
I would suggest reading Deadpool and cable 30 along with number 31 and 32, after issue three of the Civil War main title. The new secret identities of Cap And his team that are revealed by cable i’m not actually donned by the heroes until Civil War number three
After seeing the movie twice today, I really wanted to start reading the comics to see how different they are. Now that I’m seeing that there are countless issues to track down, I’m never going to read this. I was hoping I could read something like 20 issues or less and be done.
You can, just read the civil war comics and frontline, guess that’s enough if you don’t want to read all.
Getting marvel unlimited would really help you track down all the issues. Then you can pick and choose from there.
Can some one plz tell me where does the daily bugle special come in this reading order. I badly need to know it to read it properly in the order. Plz help me.
you forget thunderbird
这个列表让阅读“漫威无限”变得更加容易。这比神奇的“推荐阅读顺序”好多了。
One thing I noticed though is that Captain America/Iron Man: Casualties of War is actually listed as Iron man/Captain America. Not a big deal, but I was scrolling through the captain america comics trying to figure out where it was for longer than I should have.
糟糕的是，漫威的全套精装书似乎不会按照上面的顺序同步所有的问题。相反，他们有一本《神奇四侠》，另一本《x战警》，《蜘蛛侠》，....
Would have been nice if it was in the reading order. Just not sure if it is worth getting if I have to constantly switch volumes. Any suggestions? Or am I incorrect?
Hi dave great list but is there a reason black panther #17 was listed before. Frontline and Amazing spiderman #532 one of the comments made during the wedding blows the lid off of Peter’s decision to come out and i dont see any reason why it cant be placed after these issues
Nevermind, just realized that it was black panther #18 that i read not #17.
Keep up the good work been reading since avengers disassembled and loving it ever since.
Ok cool Glad you’re enjoying and thanks for the feedback!
Hello!
I love Your website, and have been following your guide on a daily basis for 5 years now, slowly getting through your entire marvel reading order.
我目前正在阅读内战部分，伟大是惊人的，但从上面的列表中，事情变得非常混乱，从《神奇蜘蛛侠》536和以后(主要是蜘蛛侠的问题)。他们似乎被放在了错误的位置，尤其是这些问题表明，你应该之前读过《内战6》。
Also Blade and Ghostrider seem to be in the wrong spots.
不管怎样，我喜欢你的指导，谢谢你的帮助。
嗨，伙计，我曾经是一个狂热的读者，在无限战争、凤凰传奇等时期，我也曾经是一个独立作家，但艰难的时期，毒品、酒精和女人让我摆脱了。现在我戒掉了，努力赶上进度。尤其是在电影上映前，这个故事情节。我的问题是，什么是最好的购买方式?我宁愿尽可能多地收集一些“藏书”，然后再买一些个人不需要的书。And gonna wait to collect all before even starting to read em.
Currently I only have
Road to Civil War: New Avengers: Illuminati; Amazing Spider-Man #529-531; Fantastic Four #536 & 537.
Civil War: #1-7
Thanks bud! oh and have cpt am civil war collection book and FF collection book being delivered. so that knocks about, what, 10 books off the list?
doh! i scrolled passed the trade timeline! my mistake, great list, thanks!
Enjoy the comics
非常感谢您列出平装书的订单清单!我以这种方式收集漫画(因为我是一个喜欢花很多钱来获得拿着一本书的效果的傻瓜)，我总是发现很难弄清楚如何阅读事件，如果他们没有明确地标记它们，以什么顺序阅读。
Glad you enjoy!
Has the Marvel Unlimited suggested reading order been changed/updated since it was listed here? Take a look:http://marvel.com/comics/discover/114/civil-war-the-complete-event
The ordering is different and some books don’t even appear (e.g. She-Hulk #9). However, I like the event order listed here better than the one listed on MU.
Hey so just a little misstep in the order I noticed iron man number 13 showed something bad happen to Happy but in civil war number 3 and 4 which you have at about 3 issues after he’s perfectly fine, is that the comic writers fault or just a small mistake on your guy’s part?
我认为这是漫威延续的一个小问题。你可以想象在《内战4》之后再读《钢铁侠》第13集，但托尼的整个视频已经不太管用了。所以这是一个公平的观点，但很难确定。
啊是有意义的!实际上我刚刚完成所有的问题,该死的是我喜欢这个网站的好男人你惊人的工作,这将作为我最喜欢的惊奇事件及其主要是由于你的阅读顺序给这样一个巨大的冲突的范围从所有可能的角度我爱它保持良好的工作不赏识我向我所有的朋友推荐你阅读漫画,得到新的人只是因为他们终于有一个指南,所以跟感谢一切for replying to my pretty much useless question lol
Haha I’m very glad you like it! Thanks for sharing and I hope you continue to do so.
In the Road to Civil War section it has the New Avengers: Illuminati. Is that the whole paperback or isssues X through X? I found Issue #1 and was wondering if I need the rest. Thanks. Slowly I am collecting all of these and cannot wait to read them.
There’s an unnumbered solo issue of New Avengers: Illuminati that has the “Road to Civil War” banner at the top of the cover. Issue #1 of the series is presumably after this meeting.
Thanks for putting this together! It’s hard to be a casual fan without getting totally lost or totally sucked in. I know this is totally subjective, but what would you consider the most essential TPBs? Like I said I’m more of a casual Marvel reader, and I’d like to get as much of the story with as few books as possible. I don’t need every little thing, but I know I’ll want more than just what is in the Civil War trade. Based on this list and earlier comments, besides the CW trade itself, it seems like the other main ones are Road, Frontline, and Amazing Spiderman. Are there any other really important ones? I assume Cap and Iron Man? And really, thanks again for doing this. The comics industry is designed to be a crazy rabbit hole that gets you buying a zillion books a month, so it’s really great to have people like you creating a middle ground for people like me to stand on
Few people I’ve spoken to have mentioned Spider-Ham having a civil war tie in. I’ve purchased this but have no idea where in the reading order to insert this? Any ideas?
Also it looks like there is 3 issues of Ghost Rider with Casualties of War headings.
I believe Spider-Ham would work as an epilogue to the event.
只是好奇，有没有什么特别的原因使鬼骑(第4系列)# 9-11从这个名单?
Really doesn’t have much to do with Civil War. Those issues do get the “Casualties of War” banner, so you can absolutely read at the end of the event.
感谢您的回复!我的意思是说，做得太棒了!
Thank you!
谢谢，我很高兴你喜欢!
Hi, thanks for your breakdown! I have a question: do you maybe know where I can buy the complete collection for a normal price? I think around $100,- same price as on marvel, but I don’t want it digital. Thanks for your help!
100美元是买不到全套的，我最近在ebay上只看到一套，330英镑，大约440美元。
I’m around 18 short so far and have spent in the region of £300.
哦,好的,谢谢!然后我想我会选择数字版，或者漫威无限版。这值得吗?
漫威无限无疑是性价比最高的。Here’s my take onwhether it’s worth it.
Where would you put underworld #1-5 in the chronology?
Sorry to ask another without a reply but is the astonishing Spider-Man anything to do with Civil war?
嗨，新太漫画，但一直喜欢漫威内战的想法。
Great guide by the way really helped me empty my bank account
I’m really struggling to find the Blade #4 comic and from what I’ve seen of it it doesn’t look like it’s a tie in like #5 does. Is #4 definitely a civil war tie in?
再次感谢。
Blade’s a pretty loose tie-in. And skimming through #4 just now it kind of looks like he just fights Santa… I can’t take that off the list. But I need to take a closer look at that one, good call!
Also, regarding the suggested reading order, shouldn’t the reading order reflect:
Amazing Spider-Man #529 – Begins with flashback of many years ago; Transitions to one month ago.
New Avengers Illuminati #1 – Begins with Illuminati meeting of many years ago; Culminates with Illuminati meeting that happens immediately prior to events of ASM #530
Incredible Hulk #92 – Elaborates “Hulk” events alluded to in Illuminati #1
Amazing Spider-Man #530 – Immediately follows Illuminati #1
Fantastic Four #536 – #537 – No mention of timing of events (if I remember correctly) – Could probably even read after ASM #531
Amazing Spider-Man #531 – Immediately follows ASM #530
Civil War: Opening Shot #1
Civil War: Opening Shot #1
Civil War #1
How do you know Amazing Spiderman 529 happened many years ago?
I’m hoping that would explain Tony’s flip flop from arguing against it in that story, to being for registration in both the Illuminati AND throughout Civil War itself.
I’ve always been confused by his (what seemed to be very quick) change of attitude.
I tried to find a correct reading order but I found a lot of different lists in different orders and even different comics in it. The “official” order on the Marvel website seems to be incorrect because they didn’t even have Civil war #5 in there.
I’ve read this comics already in that exact order:
#Prologue
The Invincible Iron Man Execute Program Part 1 to 6 of 6.
#Stamford Disaster
New Avengers: Illuminati
Amazing Spider-Man #529
Amazing Spider-Man #530
Amazing Spider-Man #531
Fantastic Four #536
Fantastic Four #537
Civil War #1
现在我不知道该去哪里。这里是第八名女绿巨人，其他地方是第532名神奇蜘蛛侠，其他地方是第21名新复仇者联盟。我该怎么办?
Roll with the Comic Book Herald reading order
In all seriousness, I really like the guide we have here. It’s gone through a few revisions, and multiple comic book fans ordering it in the best possible order.
That said, Marvel events are not always completely, 100% linear. We try to get as close to linear as possible, though, so I’d encourage you to give the order here a try.
Curious, does the New Avengers Prelude (just dropped 03/10) fit neatly directly in front of The Road to Civil War, replacing it as the event starting point?
Thanks –
如果你有这个问题的链接，我可以看看。不知道是哪一个。
http://www.amazon.com/Civil-War-Prelude-New-Warriors/dp/0785193618/ref=sr_1_29?ie=UTF8&qid=1427114895&sr=8-29&keywords=marvel+civil+war
Collecting New Avengers (2005) #1-6
啊，新勇士，是的，你可以读《内战之路》这是内战1号的背景信息。
Oh man, I typed New Avengers. Just realized. Haha. Thanks for the reply
我点了这个…我还需要什么吗?(我只是想在电影中使用它)干杯!
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Civil-War-Mark-Millar/dp/1905239602/ref=pd_sim_b_3?ie=UTF8&refRID=1TEDTRC18AK2T1W0EB9Z
If I were to start reading the civil war trade paperbacks, are the tie-ins absolutely necessary? Would the plot be understandable without massive holes in?
当我第一次接触漫画的时候，我读了《内战》，没有任何搭配，这在很大程度上是可以理解的。我的大部分问题都来自漫威U的状态(雷神在哪里?蜘蛛侠和钢铁侠是好兄弟?)
简而言之，我读过《内战》，如果你感兴趣的话，可以回去补上相关内容。在我看来，《超凡蜘蛛侠》和《前线》的搭配总是为故事增添了很多亮点。
I can see that Thor isn’t relevant to Civil War, and I have looked at the Thor-specific reading order, but where would you fit in JMS Thor in this timeline (aka do those Thor events happen before/during/after Civil war or does that even matter?)
I have the Civil War trade and JMS Thor Vol. 1, also planning on getting Road to Civil War as it seems important.
Love these guides btw (:
I cannot seem to find where the 5 comic House of M Civil War series fits in the civil war reading order. Any help would be appreciated.
That series actually goes withHouse of M.
Thanks for the lists!
Just one question (newby to comics). If I buy all the items listed on the ‘Civil War Trade Reading Timeline’ (which are mostly combined comics) do I have every comic listed on the ‘Marvel Unlimited Event Reading Order’? Or do I still need to order some individual comics?
Regards,
Wesley
I was wondering the same thing. Anybody?
For the most part, yes. There are a handful of characters that don’t have a “Civil War” trade, such as She-Hulk, Blade, and Cable & Deadpool.
ForShe-Hulk by Dan Slott: The Complete Collection Volume 2 (She-Hulk: the Complete Collection)
She-Hulk
ForCable & Deadpool
ForHeroes for Hire(I just missed this one the first time around)
And then for some of the odds and ends:
Civil War Companion (Marvel Comics)
Civil War Companion
AndCivil War: Marvel Universe
Civil War: Marvel Universe (note that this trade overlaps w/ the Cap Civil War trade).
Then finally, for the fallout, there’sThe Death of Captain America, Vol. 1: The Death of the Dream
Captain America #25 andFallen Son: The Death of Captain America
Fallen Son.
That should darn near cover everything. Enjoy the comics!
Thanks for all of this – one question I had (as a newbie) was what your recommendations are for getting my hands on all of these. I’m really into the tie-ins and have been enjoying the collected works so far, but I’m trying to figure out how to read everything affordably.
For context – I am reading digitally on a Kindle Fire. The Comixology app reader is awesome…the resolution looks good, it fills the screen width, etc. On the other hand, more subscription-based stuff like Marvel Unlimited or Scribd pales in terms of the digital reader (in fact, MU isn’t even available for Kindle. I had to side-load it, and it works about 1/2 the time).
Given that the Comixology reading experience is so dreamy, I tend toward that, but what I’ve realized (per your guide) is that I’d need to buy 6-8 trade paperbacks (or numerous single comics) via Comixology in order to get through the next few events (i.e. She-Hulk #8, Wolverine #42 and so on). That said, the cost does start to add up.
什么好主意吗?是否有一种订阅式的Kindle体验很棒的服务是我错过的?
For whatever reason, the Kindle has definitely gotten the short end of the stick for digital comics subscriptions. Marvel Unlimited has had a challenging time just keeping up with Android. That’s too bad to hear it isn’t a real viable Kindle solution because that’s without a doubt the best value to read all these books.
You mention Scribd, so I assume you’ve given the free trial a shot. TheCivil War selectionis pretty spotty there – MU has a lot more. Marvel Unlimited and Scribd are the only two subscription services I know of that offer Marvel books.
我希望我有一个更好的秘密答案给你，但Comixology将为你提供最好的数字体验。
也就是说，我也会考虑亚马逊上的二手TPBs(通常可以很便宜地买到)或者——一直以来最好的选择——你当地的图书馆。我的图书馆里有很多漫画，所以为了省钱值得一看!
谢谢。那我还是用Comixology吧。我把每次只买6-7期当作阅读方式。大到目前为止。
Any cant-miss series I should check out?
This list is awesome, and I have spent about 3 months acquiring the trades listed at the beginning. Knowing that I also purchased the Heroes for Hire Civil War, and Death of Captain America Vol. 1, is it necessary to purchase the She Hulk, Cable and Deadpool, and Marvel Universe trades, or are they just loose tie ins? Thanks in advance!
Hi, I’m not entirely sure what page to post this on, but this seems like the most relevant page…
I would like to start reading the Thor TPBs starting post-Civil War roughly up to the modern day. I know the post-Civil War Thor comics start with J. Michael Straczynski’s run, but I am getting a bit lost on where it goes from there… Any chance you could help?
Thanks, Jack
haha, I am in the same boat, picked up Thor Vol. 1 by JMS out of curiosity because I liked the movie and since then try to read the entire run and, boy!, is it complicated. One would think it would just go Thor Vol1, Thor vol2, thor vol 3 thor vol 4, thor vol 5 etc, no, extremely complicated.
But Dave recently posted a Thor reading order
//www.e-fidanlik.com/thor-reading-order/
which is a tremendous help, especially since he posted Amazon links (although not entirely helping, since I live in germany)
What you want is everything in chapter IV) and onwards.
I have tremendous fun reading the Thor story and I hope you will have as much fun as I have.
Hello I just recently bought my first comic book (or collection of comic books) and it just happened to be Civil War, but I was a bit disappointed that it didnt include the death of Captain America and although I plan on buying them all I really want to know which collection it would be in.
The Death of Cap story arc is told within the Captain America series, and canbe found here. Enjoy!
嘿，我正在看宇宙漫威的东西，我来到了湮灭:征服的开头。当我要继续讲宇宙的东西时，我突然对地球上的内战很感兴趣。这个列表会在什么时候与Nova的回家点相交:在这个列表结束之后，或者在中间的某个点?
我也很好奇，我是否能够在不添加附加内容的情况下快速浏览《Civil War》的主要部分，并将故事作为《Nova 1-7》的背景。
Top of my head it’s Nova #2 that he comes to Earth. This is after Civil War has ended, and the earthbound Marvel U is in The Initiative stage of registered heroes.
你完全可以做主要的内战问题，没有背景的Nova。应该有很好的掩护。
谢谢你在这里所做的一切。Very nice work, but I have 4 questions/comments/concerns:
#1 – You have left out Amazing Spider-Man #530 which is included in the TPB Road To Civil War. I am guessing this is an oversight as you likely intended it to be connected with either #529 or #530.
#2 – You have Civil War: The Return twice on your list (at 79 and 123 by my count) I am not sure what happened here.
#3 – Near the end, you list Fantastic Four #534 (which actually was published the previous year) I am guessing you meant to indicate #543-#544
#4 – Your list does not include 3 other issues which are included in the Comixology Civil War Bundle from near the end: Iron Man: Director of S.H.I.E.L.D. # 15, Mighty Avengers #1 and Avengers: The Initiative. Is this because you view these issues as part of a different story arch?
Thanks again for your work.
谢谢你的帮助，巴里!
In regards to the last question, I consider those issues transitional – from Civil War to the next stage in the MU – but not a part of the Civil War event. Certainly don’t discourage reading them once you’re done with the event, but that’s why.
再次感谢。我真的很感激你这么快就做出了反应。另外，我很高兴你把我的评论当作反馈，而不是批评。
继续努力吧!
I actually found a “marvel civil way check list” can I go by that for continuity?
当然这是一个选择，但通常发行商的清单是基于发行日期的。这并不总是(甚至通常)呈现最好的阅读顺序，我在这里尝试创建。
谢谢你！作为漫画书的新手，所有这些都让人非常困惑。我对《内战》很感兴趣，因为我听说它很不错，但在亚马逊上输入“漫威内战”，结果可能会有无数次点击。
Now I ordered Road to Civil War and Civil War (208 pages… whoa). But I have to admit, I don’t know what a Tie-in trade is (non native speaker). I assume these are sidestories told inbetween the main story? Let’s see if I get some of those
You pretty much have it. A publisher like Marvel has series of comic books that run year-round. For example, Amazing Spider-Man is available as a single issue every month (or sometimes multiple times per month) on Wednesdays (new comic book day!). For parts of the year, Amazing Spider-Man is telling stories about Peter Parker and his adventures as Spidey. When an event launches (like Civil War), suddenly Spidey’s universe is embroiled in this larger Universe-wide event. So Amazing Spider-Man as an individual series becomes a tie-in, explaining how Spider-Man fits into the overall event, and providing more detail from Spidey’s point of view on the overarching narrative.
有些捆绑销售与某一事件的关系要比其他的直接得多。在上面的例子中，《超凡蜘蛛侠内战》的搭配确实为故事增添了不少内容。有些——例如，月亮骑士——并没有给故事增加多少内容，但从技术上讲，确实与漫威的同一时期有关。
Hope that helps clear this up some!
只是想知道你觉得《月亮骑士》07、08、09(可能还有10)在“内战”的故事弧线中处于什么位置。“月亮骑士”(07,08,09)是“战争的伤亡”的问题(第十期继续“午夜太阳”的故事线开始于07,08,09)?
Thanks for your help.
好问题。月亮骑士#7 - #10可以在内战#5后阅读。在指南中更新!
What volume would moon knight 7-10 be then cause I can’t seem to find the casualties of war series of Moon Knight